Role Of Intuition And Mindfulness On Problem-Solving:– A Review

The aim of this review was to understand the features and functions of two apparently conflicting constructs “intuition” and “mindfulness” with specific focus on problem solving. Literature published between 2010 and 2020 was searched and retrieved from data bases including Research Gate, PsycINFO, EBSCO, Crossref, Medline, PubMed and Scopus, using the key words “intuition”, “mindfulness”, “intuition and problem solving”, “mindfulness and problem solving” and “intuition and mindfulness” for the study. The relationship between the two constructs was analysed within the dual process system of information processing. It was also investigated whether mindfulness would facilitate access to intuition and contribute to problem solving, or function complementary to each other. Analysis of published literature revealed that while the construct ‘intuition’ could be fitted into non-conscious system of cognitive process, the construct ‘mindfulness’ was related to conscious cognitive processing system, and therefore appeared to be contradictory. A critical evaluation of the relationship between the two constructs revealed a symbiotic relationship and emphasized the need to develop an integrated model to trigger intuition in mindful state with regard to problem-solving or decision-making.

According to Stanovich & West (2000), the "intuitive pathway (System 1) processing is contextually dependent, associative, heuristic, tacit, intuitive and implicit/automatic in nature; hence, it is relatively undemanding in terms of its use of scarce cognitive resources". In contrast, "the deliberate pathway (System 2) processing is contextually independent, rule-based, analytic and explicit in nature; hence, it is relatively slow and makes great demands on cognitive resources". Both processes have their benefits and limitations.
An integrative approach would have a symbiotic effect in the process of problem-solving. 'Intuition' and 'mindfulness' are two constructs that have attracted the researchers for problem-solving and decisionmaking, working in diverse domains including executives in management, health care systems, education etc. An analysis of these constructs would reveal a contradictory nature between them but a critical evaluation would indicate that they can function symbiotically.

Intuitionfeature, functions and role in problem-solving
Pretz & Totz (2007) based on the analysis of theoretical and empirical studies on intuition which included both contemporary and historical studies, classified intuition as three distinct types: "1 holistic, 2 inferential, and 3 affective". According to their classification all three types of intuitions are judgements but differ in the process associated with arriving at these judgements. Holistic judgements are arrived at involving qualitative, non-analytic process which integrates multiple and diverse inputs. The process associated with holistic intuitive judgement is not explicit in nature. Inferential intuition is related to the decision-making process which was analytic in nature but had become automated and intuitive. Affective intuition involves emotional reactions to problem situations.
Gerard P. Hodgkinson, Janice Langan-Fox and Eugene Sadler-Smith (2008) have critically analysed the relevance of intuition in behavioural sciences and distinguished intuition from related constructs such as insight, tacit knowledge, implicit learning and knowledge, instinct, insight and creativity and its place in dual processing system. They also identified the challenges in investigating intuition with regard to theoretical frameworks and methods for valid and reliable empirical research. The theoretical framework for studying intuition mainly include: 1. Dual process cognitive theory where intuition is placed in non-conscious cognitive process, 2. Processoutcome framework which analyses each type of intuition into either intuitive judgement or intuitive insight, 3. Phenomenon based for analysing non stereotypical intuitions.

Mindfulnessdefinition, practice and benefits
The term mindfulness also does not have a single precise definition. Kabat-Zinn (1994) has described mindfulness as "paying attention in a particular way: on purpose, in the present moment, and nonjudgmentally." Kristeller (1999) defined mindfulness as "bringing one's complete attention to the present experience on a moment-to-moment basis". Marlatt & Kristeller (1999) suggested that "mindfulness is observing one's experiences with an attitude of acceptance and loving kindness". According to Segal et al. (2002) "in mindfulness practice, the focus of a person's attention is opened to admit whatever enters experience, while at the same time, a stance of kindly -curiosity allows the person to investigate whatever appears, without falling prey to automatic judgments or reactivity". Brown & Ryan (2003) have stated mindfulness as "a receptive attention to and awareness of present events and experience". They also stated that mindfulness is different from behaving mechanically. Mechanical behaviour which is also described as automatic pilot occurs without awareness of one's actions. Kabat-Zinn (2003) stated that "mindfulness includes an affectionate, compassionate quality within the attending, a sense of openhearted friendly presence and interest". According to Kabat-Zinn (2003), Mindfulness is not only of experiences of the present moment prevailing in the environment but also primarily concerned about clear awareness of one's thoughts, emotions, sensations and actions. Marlatt and Bishop et al. (2004), defined mindfulness as "a process of regulating attention in order to bring a quality of non-elaborative awareness to current experience and a quality of relating to one's experience within an orientation of curiosity, experiential openness, and acceptance".

Intuition and problem-solving
The role of intuition in problem-solving in various domains includes education, management, clinical settings etc has been empirically investigated.
Chih-Hsien Huang (2015) analysed the students' ability to decide on the truth value of mathematical statements with unknown truth values with the theoretical framework offered by Fischbein. This framework classified intuition into affirmatory intuition, conjectural intuition, anticipatory intuition, or conclusive. Analysis of the results revealed that students use affirmatory and anticipatory intuitions in deciding on truth values of mathematical statements.
A study by Chih-Hsien Huang (2015) on problem-solving styles revealed that female students used more intuitive problem-solving styles than male students.
Kenneth J.Gilhooly (2016) reviewed the beneficial impact of incubation in creative problem-solving tasks. The beneficial effect of incubation period is attributed to the theories of unconscious work (UTT) and beneficial forgetting.
Arwanto, I Ketut Budayasa and Mega Teguh Budiarto (2018) in an explorative qualitative study on students' intuition on Polya mathematical problem-solving process found that subject of student intuition in solving mathematical problems at the stage of understanding mathematical problems uses three intuition that can help understand the mathematical problems. They are: 1. Self-evident intuition 2. Intrinsic certainty intuition, and 3. Perseverance induced intuitions at the stages of Polya problem solving process. Melvin Princea, and Constantinos Priporas (2018) have investigated the role of intuition in bridging the gap between class room learning and the required competencies for employment and career advancement in business organizations by implementing an intervention model Intuitive Awakening Elicitation (IAE). The goal of the model was on developing and nurturing students' intuitive skills for marketing decision-making. The study emphasized the need of integrating strategies to access and employ intuitive resources in academic programs.
Elijah Chudnoff (2019) analysed the role of intuition in problem-solving ability particularly with regard to mathematical problem-solving. Contrary to the stereotypical classification of intuition identified involvement of three types of intuition based on the phenomenon associates with the process. The three types are: "hard-won intuitions, 2. improved intuitions, and 3. expertly guided intuitions".
The limited number of empirical studies on role of intuition on problem-solving / decision-making in various domains of education reveals the scope for further investigation for developing and application of models for accessing and using intuition in problem-solving and decision -making situations.

Relationship between intuition, mindfulness and problem-solving / decision-making
From the definitions, features and functions, it is obvious that the two constructs -intuition and mindfulness -fit into different domains of cognitive functions. While intuition fits into non-conscious system (system 1) of cognitive process, mindfulness is associated with awareness and therefore fits into system 2 (conscious) of cognitive domain. Therefore, these two appear to be contradictory. Brown and Ryan (2003) have found a positive relationship between mindfulness and the extent of harmony between the explicit and implicit emotions experienced by individuals suggesting mindfulness may trigger access to non-conscious phenomenon like intuition. The term mindful intuition has entered the academic and research domains recently. Literature on studies relating to mindfulness, intuition and problem-solving / decision-making is limited in number. Analysis of available literature revealed mixed outcome regarding impact of mindfulness to trigger intuitive problem-solving.
Erik Dane Jesse H. Jones and Michael G. Pratt (2009) argue that mindfulness not only refers to awareness and attention to the present moment and events surrounding the individual, but also applies to the cognitive and emotional processes that occur within the individual.
Munich University of Applied Sciences and Ludwig-Maximilians-University Munich, has introduced the innovative Munich Model in the curriculum since 2010. The course facilitates students to learn the theory and practice of mindfulness and meditation through for-credit (ECTS) courses. The program also teaches students to incorporate these practices in their own professional work as psychologists, teachers and social workers. Research has revealed that the regular practice of meditation in addition to improving the abilities like concentration, compassion, stress management and the regulation of emotions, also enhance overall physical and mental well-being in general. The skills learnt through this course impact both performance and creativity among the students.
Robert Drummond McNaughton (2013) studied the management styles of executive meditators. The study explored the relationship between use of meditation and intuition in decision-making among executive meditators. The study found that the meditators used their intuition in the majority of their decisions. They reported their intuition was more accurate, subsequent to meditation.
In an empirical study, Carina Remmersa, Sascha Topolinskib and Johannes Michalaka (2014) found a negative relationship between trait mindfulness and performance involving intuitive judgement task.
Claire M. Zedileus and Jonathan W. Schooler (2015) have found a negative relationship between mindfulness and insight in creative problem-solving task and found that participants in more mindful state adopted analytic approach (system 2) to the task. Tejpavan Singh Gandhok (2015) in his master's thesis has investigated the influence of mindfulness to the beneficial use of intuitive resources in decision-making.
Cherie elaine oertel (2016) for enhancing awareness of intuitive resources and enabling the integration of System 1 (intuition) and System 2 (rationality) cognitive processes in career decision-making developed a mindfulness-based intervention model named Post-Engagement Reflection (PER). The model was used to study post occupational engagement activity. The results of the experimental study revealed that individuals who completed the PER in along with the interview stated more intuition-related information in response to their open-ended questions than the control group.
However, the beneficial effect of mindfulness in multiple domains of cognitive function including intuition is being recognised and incorporated in several academic and executive training programs.
Melvin Princea and Constantinos Priporas (2018) have developed Intuitive Awakening Elicitation (IAE) model to bridge the gap in the required work place competencies and the knowledge and skills acquired from academic program. The study emphasized that business schools might recognize the importance of intuition for a new business model, in addition to their focus on traditional analytical models to effectively handle the changing situation in the business arena.

Conclusion
The analysis of the constructs intuition and mindfulness revealed that though these constructs appear to be conflicting with regard to the domain of their cognitive function, mindfulness practice could trigger intuition and contribute to solve problems / take decisions effectively. The analysis offers the scope for developing models for integrating the strategies of practicing mindfulness, and accessing and using intuition for problemsolving / decision-making, and empirical studies on their impact and mechanism of action.